The short answer
Sometimes. Gerard Shake PRO is a direct-to-deck system — no strapping or battens are used — and it can be installed over qualifying existing shingles, subject to roof conditions. Whether your roof qualifies is something we confirm on site, not over the phone.
Other stone-coated products, including DECRA and Metstar, have their own installation requirements. We follow the requirements for the product you choose.

What has to be true for an overlay to make sense
During the assessment we look at the existing roof from above and, where possible, from the attic. Things that matter include:
- How many layers are already on the roof. An existing roof that has already been re-shingled over once is a different situation from a single layer.
- The condition of the deck. Soft spots, rot, sagging or water staining in the attic mean the deck needs attention first, which means removing the shingles over those areas at a minimum.
- How flat the existing surface is. Badly curled or lifted shingles can telegraph through and affect how panels sit.
- Ventilation. A new roof is the right time to make sure the attic can breathe; an overlay should not trap moisture.
- Flashing details at chimneys, walls, skylights and valleys, which are always rebuilt for the new roof regardless.
- Any requirements that apply to your property, which we confirm as part of the project.
Benefits when the roof qualifies
Leaving qualifying shingles in place avoids tear-off labour and disposal, keeps the house covered during the job and reduces mess around the property. Those savings are real, but they should never come at the expense of covering up a deck problem.
When the old roof should come off
If the deck is damaged, there are several existing layers, or the product or local requirements call for it, the existing roofing is removed. Your written quotation should state clearly which approach is planned, what is included in tear-off and disposal, and how any deck repairs discovered during the work will be handled.
What stays the same either way
Whether we install over existing shingles or onto a stripped deck, the details are the same: new underlayment and protection membranes where the system calls for them, new metal valleys, new flashing at every wall, chimney and skylight, and interlocking panels with hidden fasteners. The 50-year transferable product warranty and our 12-year labour warranty apply, subject to their written terms.
This guide is general information for homeowners. Product specifications, warranties and promotions are subject to the applicable written terms. Ask us about your specific roof.


